Nursing Homes vs. Assisted Living: How Do I Know What’s Right for My Parent?

Nursing Homes vs. Assisted Living in Manhattan Beach : How Do I Know What’s Right for My Parent?

Nursing homes or Skilled Nursing Facilities (SNFs) and Assisted Living Communities are basically the same thing, right? Wrong!

Although these senior care solutions have similar goals, they refer to very different living arrangements.

Your choice will ultimately depend on your loved one’s medical needs, mental state, and personal preferences.

With that in mind, today’s post is meant to help you make the right choice. Read on to learn when it’s time to move to a nursing home, and whether assisted living will work for your loved one, courtesy of the ABC Manhattan Beach team.

When is it Time to Move to a Nursing Home?

Health Services Research suggests that the likelihood of spending some time in a nursing home is relatively high. In fact, around 40% of all seniors 65 or older will receive care in a nursing home setting at some point in their lives (Taylor et al., 2005, p. 811).

A number of studies have been conducted to identify main predictors of seniors moving to nursing homes. Using the meta-analysis provided by the Health Services Research journal in conjunction with AARP criteria, we have constructed the following nursing home user profile.

Assisted Living Community residents come from older adults (65+) and those who are living with disabilities, 60 years or older. Additionally, it may be time for the “big move” if your parent struggles to:

  • Access the telephone in an emergency;
  • Shop without assistance;
  • Prepare adequate meals without assistance;
  • Perform basic housekeeping duties;
  • Maintain their personal hygiene;
  • Keep a proper medical regiment without assistance;
  • Travel outside the home for day trips and errands.

At this point, it’s important to mention that many of these limitations can be overcome through home-based long-term care. However, if your loved one struggles with structural features in the home, lives with a disability or chronic illness, or otherwise requires more intensive, round-the-clock care, Assisted Living Community might be the best option.

Is Assisted Living Right for My Parent or Loved One?

Contrary to what you may have heard, Assisted Living care is only a subset of the long-term care continuum.

Assisted Living Communities play a vital role in the senior care continuum.

Some Assisted Living Communities can be quite expensive–ranging from $40,000 to $100,000 per year according to the Health Services Journal.  Although the are Communities that offer shared rooms for the lower income individuals.

In contrast to nursing homes, Assisted Living Communities do not offer medical care. If your loved one could benefit from assistance with the activities of daily living, and longs for a place they can still call home, Assisted Living Community might be right for them.

Free Service to Find Assisted Living Community Through Your Resource in Manhattan Beach, California

If you need more help determining what’s right for you, Always Best Care Manhattan Beach representatives are standing by.

Contact our team at to start you free assisted living referral and placement service. You can find full details about what this entails by calling 310-984-6706.


Cohen, M. A., Tell, E. J., & Wallack, S. S. (1988). The Risk Factors of Nursing Home Entry Among Residents of Six Continuingcommunities. Journal of Gerontology, 43(1), S15-S21.

Taylor Jr, D. H., Osterman, J., Will Acuff, S., &Østbye, T. (2005). Do seniors understand their risk of moving to a nursing home?.Health Services Research, 40(3), 811-828.

Posted In: in home care